Sonntag, 20. März 2011

What's your opinion ?



I have made this bouquet longer time ago,perhaps you remember?!
Now I have to arrange them again ,but I'm not sure which kind of pot looks better :-( ! Could you please help me ? The first one is a simple pot which I have painted and the second is from Elisabeth Causeret.

Kommentare:

May hat gesagt…

a mi me gusta el primero más, las flores son preciosas

Drora's minimundo hat gesagt…

I really like both arrangements but the second looks more elegant.

Karin hat gesagt…

mir würde das erste Arrangement besser gefallen.

carol's clay.handiwork hat gesagt…

both are very good, and if i need to choose one of them, i will choose the second one, because when it pair with the chair, it looks better.

Margriet hat gesagt…

I think the first one looks a bit more formal and the second one has more of a country feel about it! I like the second one better!!!
The flowers are very beautiful by the way :-)

Marian hat gesagt…

Ambos quedan preciosos pero depende del lugar donde esten colocadas.
Si se ponen directamente en el suelo, el primero.
Si son para una ventana, sobre un mueble.... el segundo.
Besos

rosanna hat gesagt…

I love the second one. The first one is nice but a bit too formal for my liking.Your fowers are, as usual, gorgeous! Rosanna

Morena Ciambra Dreamartdolls hat gesagt…

OH! How beautiful!!! I love the look of the first one best but both are AMAZING!
XXX
Morena

Un Taller de Miniaturas hat gesagt…

Your flowers look great with both of them, but perhaps I like the first one. I think it depends on the place you put one or another pot.
Hugs,
Paloma

Jollie hat gesagt…

I like the first one better :)
Beautiful flower arrangement by the way!! (did not see them before)

Hugs Jollie

dat Bea hat gesagt…

Wohin möchtest du das Arrangement denn platzieren? Das erste ist sehr formal, passt aber hervorragend zu einer klassischen Einrichtung. Das zweite ist besonders mit dem Stuhl moderner, gefiele mir gut auf einer Terasse oder so.
So oder so sind die Blumen herrlich!

Catherine hat gesagt…

I love the urn! Though they are both lovely.

Garden of Miniatures hat gesagt…
Dieser Kommentar wurde vom Autor entfernt.
Garden of Miniatures hat gesagt…

Thanks for your opinions :-)! The flowers haven't a special place and I used the chair only for the photo.I just wanted to know,which kind of pot you like better.Until now the score is even,lol:-)

Die Blumen müssen vorerst nirgends hinpassen und gehören auch nicht zum Stuhl.Ich wollte ganz allgemein wissen,was ihr denkt,welcher Topf sich dafür besser eignet.Bis jetzt steht es unentschieden,grins :-)

Andrea Thieck Miniatures hat gesagt…

Ach so, auf den Pott kommt es Dir an... Ich bin sonst nämlich genau der Ansicht von dat Bea. Aber das gilt eigentlich auch für den Pott. Also laß doch einfach die endgültige Entscheidung, bis Du weißt, wo es hin soll. Die Blumen sind so oder so wieder wunderschön.
LG Andrea

Arantxa hat gesagt…

They are lovely!!
i prefer the first photo.

Josje hat gesagt…

Although generally I like informal bouquets, in this case I like the first arrangement best. The urn lifts the bouquet a little bit which makes the flowers stand out better. The second vase, although very pretty, is too round for the shape of the bouquet. Well that's my opinion anyway, ;)
The flowers are very pretty, as always.

Susi hat gesagt…

Pues me gustan las dos macetas...depende de donde vaya a ir, la habitacion....pero asi de primera me gusta mas la primera foto, preciosa, las hojas me han dejado alucinando, y las rosas sin palabras, un beso.

TreeFeathers hat gesagt…

They're both lovely, but I think the second one really shows off the flowers better. It looks casual, elegant, and beautiful. The first one would look good in a formal setting. Nice work on the flowers, they're gorgeous! :)

- Grace

Alison hat gesagt…

Both Elisabeth Causeret's pot and your flowers are beautiful...though the combination in the second arrangement looks a bit too full. For that reason I'd choose the first. I'd love to see the second arrangement with perhaps two or three flowers less :)

Mieke hat gesagt…

Wunderschöne blumen, so herlich romantisch, und darum finde ich den Topf auf dem ersten Bild am schönsten bei den Blumen passen, es ergibt ein tolles gesamt Bild.
Viele Liebe Grüße Mieke

ines paiva raposo hat gesagt…

Acho que ambos ficam bem, mas o segundo fica mais elegante.
Beijinho
www.liliputthings.blogspot.com

malu2 hat gesagt…

Segun el lugar en que vaya colocado,de todad formas,los dos lucen muy bien,porque son preciosos,besos.

cunha hat gesagt…

hello, for me the first one because I like everything old, by the way the flowers are amazing, like the others you do. congratulations

Christine hat gesagt…

I think they are made for different settings. The first is more formal and elegant and I could see it in a grand house, while the second is more relaxed and country looking. Isn't it surprising the difference the pot makes. :) It is stunning either way.

Karin Corbin hat gesagt…

The flowers are lovely, they look good the way you have them arranged. But you asked about how I like the pots with them so I will answer that question.

Looking at it only with an artist eye for proportion and massing then I like the first arrangement better. The darker color of the base anchors the composition. The taller proportions of the pot complement the more linear flowers that spike out of the arrangement.

If the second pot were larger it would work better. But as it is white and small it gets a bit lost and the flowers seem rather suspended in mid air. It seems a pity for such a fine miniature pot to be a bit overwhelmed in the composition. It needs to be reserved for a time when it can live up to its own beautiful potential in an arrangement.

Eva hat gesagt…

Also ich finde ja das Arragment wunderschön aber in dem zweiten Topf find ich es noch ein Tick besser.

lg Eva

Anneke hat gesagt…

oh those flowers look so very wonderfull! I think I like the first one best, because the color makes the colors of the flowers 'pop' out more! It's also a bit more sturdy an taller than the second one, wich suits the lavishness of your bouqet. The second vase is beautifull but a little to round, white and small for your flower arrangement. That's my opinion! But I can see that the vote's are almost even now! haha

Garden of Miniatures hat gesagt…

Yes,the vote's are even :-)!But it was also my opinion that the first pot looks better.Karin gets the heart of that what I thought by looking at the two options.So I take the garden urn.Thanks for your help,it was very interesting to hear the different arguments!!!Jeannette x

CWPoppets hat gesagt…

As I do prefer modern miniatures my favourite is the second one.
Schoene Gruesse
Christine

miniacollection hat gesagt…

I love both, it depends where you want to disply the bouquet. The first one would look perfect in a classic decoration, a kind of chateau. The second one as got a country look, I think it is easier to display and can go in any kinds of setting.
I am looking forward to seeing what you're going to choose.
Geneviève

Ascension hat gesagt…

A mi personalmente me gusta mas la primera, aunque las dos son preciosas para ese arreglo yo me quedaria con la primera.
besitos ascension

Sabiha Barkey hat gesagt…

Who looks at the pots, when the flowers are so beautiful!!!! The flowers are soooooo amazing!!!

Sabihax

Maria Blanca"AyamontinoMaria" hat gesagt…

Las flores son preciosas en cualquier sitio, pero yo me quedo con la primera...Un beso.Maria

Teresa Martínez- IGMA artisan hat gesagt…

El primero.
Precioso!!!!!

1 Oak Arts hat gesagt…

Lovely work, Jeanette!

Teruka hat gesagt…

I like the first one...It´s really nice

juani hat gesagt…

las flores son preciosas y quedan muy bien en cualquiera de las dos
pero prefiero la primera

WeeLittleWest / Kathy Olaf-Obrenski hat gesagt…

I like the first one. Beautiful!!!!

Kathi hat gesagt…

Your flowers are beautiful! They would look great anywhere! I think the urn is best. Your arrangement is formal and the urn shows off your arrangement well.
Great work!

Xisca hat gesagt…

no matter the place where you put , incredibly beautiful
beautiful work
hugs, Xisca

Monica hat gesagt…

What a difficult question to answer, as both are lovely in their own right. I'd say it depends on what kind of room you'll be putting them in. The arrangement in the urn is more formal in proportion and design, and would suite something elegant and refined, while the one in the round container has a softer, more gently relaxed country feel. The fact that your floral work is so incredibly gorgeous makes me think you should do one of each ... and maybe another, using the naturally loose (bottom) arrangement in the urn, as it would be especially beautiful, and would suit any type of decor ... shabby or chic!

Dave Williams hat gesagt…

Flowers are superb and I like the first pot the best.
Dave